OATH stands for the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings - the administrative court that handles violations issued by NYC agencies including the Department of Buildings (DOB), Department of Sanitation (DSNY), Fire Department (FDNY), and Health Department (DOHMH). OATH is separate from the criminal court system.

Can I fight an OATH ticket in writing instead of appearing in person?

Yes. For most OATH violations, you can submit a written defense (called a written answer) instead of appearing in person. A well-drafted written defense addressing procedural defects, mitigating circumstances, and reduction arguments is often as effective as in-person appearance and forces you to organize arguments clearly.

What happens if I ignore an OATH ticket?

A default decision is entered against you automatically and immediately. You lose without any hearing. The full penalty is due, additional late fees are added, and the default becomes part of the building or business record. For DOB violations, defaults can also affect future permit applications. Never ignore an OATH summons.

How much is a NYC dirty sidewalk violation?

DSNY violations for dirty sidewalks, improper garbage placement, and recycling violations typically range from $100 to $4,000 depending on type and whether it is a repeat offense. First-time violations are usually on the lower end. DSNY tickets have some of the highest dismissal rates at OATH because the inspection process has strict procedural requirements that are frequently not followed correctly.

How serious is a DOB violation in NYC?

DOB violations are categorized into three classes: Class 1 (Immediately Hazardous) up to $25,000 per violation, Class 2 (Major) $3,000-$10,000 per violation, Class 3 (Lesser) $500-$3,000 per violation. Multiple violations can be issued in a single inspection, compounding quickly. Unresolved violations also appear on the building public record.

Can I fight an OATH ticket if the violation is real?

Yes - and you often should. Even if the underlying condition existed, you have the right to present mitigating circumstances, show corrective action, and argue for penalty reduction. In many cases, showing prompt correction results in a significantly reduced penalty or even dismissal. The hearing officer has discretion to consider all circumstances.

Can a Health Department violation hurt my restaurant letter grade?

Yes. Your letter grade (A, B, C) is calculated from points accumulated during inspections. Each violation has a point value. However, the initial inspection grade is not final - you have the right to request re-inspection and an OATH hearing to contest individual violations. Reducing your violation points through hearings can improve your letter grade.

What are the most common defenses to a DOB violation?

The most effective defenses include: incorrect respondent (you are not the owner or responsible party), violation already corrected, improper inspection procedure, work was authorized under a valid permit, inaccurate violation description, and statute of limitations. A defense letter should identify which of these applies to your specific summons.

Fight My OATH Ticket — NYC Violation Defense Builder

Enter Your Basic Information

Fill in what you know — you can skip anything you don't have handy

Start here

📝 Don't have your ticket with you? That's fine. Just fill in your name and hearing date — that's all you need to start. You can add the rest later. Nothing here is required except your name.

Your Name *

Violation Date

Address on Ticket

Your Hearing Date

🔍 (Optional) Have your ticket number? We can auto-fill everything above.

Who Gave You the Ticket?

Look at the top of your summons — the agency name is printed there

Fill in name first

🏗️DOBBuildings

🗑️DSNYSanitation

🔥FDNYFire

🧪DOHMHHealth

🚔NYPDPolice

💧DEPEnvironment

What Are They Saying You Did?

Pick the violation listed on your ticket — it's usually the most prominent text

Pick agency first

Answer a Few Simple Questions

Just pick what matches your situation — we do all the legal thinking

Pick violation first

How this works: Each question below matches a real legal defense. Pick what actually happened. We automatically build the strongest possible argument using real OATH appeal decisions — no legal knowledge needed.

Your Defense Strength

📎 Documents to Collect & Attach

✅ Your Defense Document Ready to Submit

🔒 PREVIEW MODE

Purchase to unlock printing — $19.99

📋 Have more than one citation on this summons? Each citation needs its own separate defense — OATH rules require each charge to be argued individually. Complete this form again for each citation. Each one is a separate $19.99 purchase and a separate document to submit.

⚠️ Your hearing is approaching — submit before your deadline

📧 Save your defense & get a hearing reminder

Optional — enter your email and we'll send you a copy + remind you before your hearing date.

Opcional — ingrese su correo y le enviaremos una copia + recordatorio antes de su audiencia.

Skip → Omitir →

Self-Service

Autoservicio

$19.99

Print + Submit

Imprimir + Enviar

Complete IRAC defense document

Documento de defensa IRAC completo

Real OATH case citations

Citas de casos OATH reales

Submission instructions

Instrucciones de envío

⭐ Attorney Included

⭐ Abogado Incluido

$49.99

Print + Attorney Call

Imprimir + Llamada con Abogado

Everything in $19.99

Todo lo de $19.99

15-min call with Ettrick Campbell, Esq.

15 min con Ettrick Campbell, Esq.

Personal case review

Revisión personal de su caso

📬 Step 5 — How to Submit Your Defense

Choose one method — click to expand full instructions

💻OnlineFastest

Go to oath.cityofnewyork.us → click "Submit Online Hearing" → paste your defense text + attach up to 3 files. Must submit before your hearing date. Save your confirmation number.

✉️By MailUse Certified Mail

Print your defense. Sign it. Send by certified mail — keep the receipt as proof. Must arrive before your hearing date.

OATH Remote Hearings Unit
66 John Street, 10th Floor
New York, NY 10038

📞By PhoneRequest 3+ days early

Email OATH at least 3 business days before your hearing to schedule. Use the email for your borough:

Brooklyn: RemoteBKLYN@oath.nyc.gov
Bronx: RemoteBronx@oath.nyc.gov
Manhattan: RemoteManhattan@oath.nyc.gov
Queens: RemoteLIC@oath.nyc.gov
Staten Island: RemoteSI@oath.nyc.gov

Include: summons numbers, your name, and a callback phone number.

Got an OATH Ticket?
If You Do Nothing, You Automatically Lose.

¿Recibió una Multa OATH?
Si No Hace Nada, Automáticamente Pierde.

Got an OATH Ticket?If You Do Nothing, You Automatically Lose.

¿Recibió una Multa OATH?Si No Hace Nada, Automáticamente Pierde.

Got an OATH Ticket?
If You Do Nothing, You Automatically Lose.

¿Recibió una Multa OATH?
Si No Hace Nada, Automáticamente Pierde.